Peer Review Process
- Introduction
Economivera: Journal of Business, Economics and Management (JBEM) is committed to maintaining high standards of academic quality, integrity, and scientific publication ethics. Reviewers play an essential role in ensuring that submitted manuscripts meet the journal's standards of originality, relevance, methodological rigor, and academic contribution.
The journal invites qualified academics, researchers, and professionals with relevant expertise to participate in the peer-review process.
- Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers are expected to:
- Evaluate manuscripts objectively, fairly, and independently.
- Assess the originality and relevance of the research.
- Examine the appropriateness of the research methodology.
- Evaluate the accuracy and consistency of data analysis and interpretation.
- Provide constructive comments and recommendations to improve manuscript quality.
- Identify relevant literature that may strengthen the manuscript.
- Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process.
- Disclose any potential conflicts of interest.
- Review Criteria
Reviewers are requested to evaluate manuscripts based on the following criteria:
- Originality: The manuscript presents original ideas, findings, or contributions.
- Relevance: The topic is relevant to business, economics, and management.
- Literature Review: The manuscript provides an adequate and relevant theoretical foundation.
- Research Methodology: The research design and methods are appropriate and clearly explained.
- Results and Discussion: Findings are presented clearly and discussed logically.
- Conclusion: Conclusions are consistent with the research objectives and findings.
- References: Sources are relevant, credible, and properly cited.
- Language and Presentation: The manuscript is written clearly and follows the journal's author guidelines.
- Peer Review Process
Each manuscript submitted to JBEM undergoes an initial editorial screening before being considered for peer review.
Manuscripts that meet the journal's initial requirements may be assigned to qualified reviewers with relevant academic expertise.
Reviewers are expected to provide an objective assessment and constructive recommendations to assist the editor in making an editorial decision.
- Review Recommendations
After evaluating a manuscript, reviewers may recommend one of the following decisions:
- Accept: The manuscript is suitable for publication without further substantive revision.
- Minor Revision: The manuscript requires minor corrections before publication.
- Major Revision: The manuscript requires substantial revisions and further evaluation.
- Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's publication standards.
The final publication decision rests with the Editor.
- Confidentiality and Publication Ethics
Reviewers must treat all submitted manuscripts as confidential documents. Manuscripts must not be shared, reproduced, or used for personal or professional advantage.
Reviewers must not contact authors directly regarding the manuscript unless authorized by the editor.
Any suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, duplicate publication, or other ethical concerns should be reported confidentially to the editor.
- Conflict of Interest
Reviewers should decline an assignment if they have financial, professional, personal, or academic relationships that could compromise their impartiality.

